When Dr. Brahmbhatt was asked to deliver this year’s presidential address, his first reaction was not excitement. It was uncertainty.
Presidential addresses, he noted, are usually given by someone who has reached the summit — a person who has spent decades building departments, leading organizations, and training generations of surgeons, and who now turns around to tell us what the view looks like from the top. He is not there yet. He is still climbing. For a while he wondered whether that left him with less to say.
Then it occurred to him that the middle of the ladder might be exactly the right place to stand. From there, you can still see in both directions. He can remember what it felt like to wonder whether he belonged — the rejections, the missed opportunities, the quiet question every one of us has asked at some point about whether the sacrifice would ever prove worth it. But he has also climbed far enough to begin to see a pattern that is invisible from the bottom.
The equation we inherit
Most of us inherit a simple equation, reinforced daily by academic medicine: study harder, publish more, operate more, earn another degree, join another committee, win another grant, earn another title. We call it meritocracy, and there is real truth in it. Hard work matters. Talent matters. Discipline matters.
But as the proverb has it, if hard work alone led to success, the donkey would own the farm. Hard work is necessary. It has never been sufficient.
Preparing this address forced Dr. Brahmbhatt to ask a question he had never quite considered. Not what have I accomplished, but how did any of this actually happen? The obvious answers came first — preparation, persistence, dependability, sacrifice — and all of them are true. None of them was the whole story. The longer he looked at his own CV, the less he saw milestones and the more he saw conversations, introductions, recommendations, and acts of generosity he had nearly forgotten.
His career, he realized, was not built by achievements. It was built by people.
Two doors he never knocked on
He offered two examples, both of which he misread at the time.
Early on, he expected to go into internal medicine. Through a chain of connections he landed a research year in a basic science lab in St. Louis, where he spent most of his time at the bench and, more importantly, found a community among the general surgery residents. When an unexpected PGY-1 position opened in surgery, those residents put his name forward. A series of conversations followed between faculty members — none of which included him. He had not campaigned for the position. He had not known it existed. His surgical career began because other people saw something in him before he saw it in himself.
Years later, finishing fellowship, he had a plan: Los Angeles, where music had become an important part of his life. His division chief helped arrange exactly the interview he had hoped for — and then, unprompted, gave his name to a friend who chaired a department in Boston, and to no one else in his class. He did not get the Los Angeles job. At the time it felt like failure. He went to Boston instead and stayed eleven years, and it was there that he became the surgeon he is.
Neither of these, he said, was mentorship. Both were sponsorship. Mentors advise you; sponsors advocate for you. Mentors build your confidence; sponsors lend you theirs. Mentors talk to you. Sponsors talk about you when you are not in the room.
There is no top of the ladder
For years he assumed the point of climbing was to reach the next rung, and that eventually there would be enough — enough publications, enough recognition, enough leadership — that he would feel he had arrived. What he found instead was that the finish line keeps moving. There is no top of the ladder. There is only another rung. A career built on arriving is a life spent almost arriving.
Somewhere in the middle, the questions changed. Not what else can I achieve, but what kind of life am I building? Borrowing from David Brooks’s The Second Mountain, he described a first mountain built on achievement and a second built on commitment, relationships, and service — and observed that a CV can grow more impressive with every line while a life grows less meaningful. Success is easy to measure. Significance is not. Academic medicine counts publications, grants, h-indices, RVUs, awards, and promotions, and none of those numbers answer the question he now finds himself asking.
He does not remember his publication count from five years ago. He remembers conversations: a resident who was struggling, a patient who trusted him, a friend who showed up, his wife, his parents growing older, playing the violin. The things he remembers most are rarely the things he spent the most time chasing.
He offered a GPS as an analogy. When you miss a turn, it does not scold you or remind you what it told you three miles ago. It simply recalculates — a grace he wishes more academic surgeons extended to themselves, since careers rarely follow the route we planned. But a GPS can only recalculate the route. It cannot choose the destination. Academic medicine gives us an extraordinarily detailed roadmap — promotion criteria, productivity targets, national benchmarks — and if we are not careful, the institutional scoreboard quietly becomes our compass. You can reach every destination someone else entered for you and still feel lost when you arrive.
Leadership begins earlier than we think
As the questions changed, so did the direction he was looking. He stopped looking only at the people above him and began noticing the students, residents, fellows, and junior faculty below — people asking him the questions he once asked someone else.
Leadership, he argued, does not begin at the top of the ladder. It begins the first time someone asks your advice, the first time someone watches how you handle failure, the first time someone starts learning from your example rather than your instruction. It begins the moment you stop asking who is above you and start asking who needs you.
The purpose of climbing the ladder was never to reach another rung. It was to become one.
What this means for our society
This, he said, is why professional societies matter. Careers change one relationship at a time, and organizations create the relationships that change careers. The greatest contribution of the Society of Asian Academic Surgeons is not the annual meeting, the awards, the committee leadership opportunities, or the scholarships, remarkable as those are. It is the careers that would not otherwise have existed — students connected to faculty, residents to mentors, junior faculty to sponsors, tomorrow’s leaders to today’s.
He closed with a proverb: the day a man throws away the stick is the day he forgets it helped him walk. Some debts can never be repaid — the mentor who believed in you, the parent who sacrificed, the sponsor who carried more than their share, the attending who opened the first door. You cannot repay them. You can only honor them by becoming that person for someone else.
He closed his address by making a specific request of the room. Choose one person — not ten, just one — a few rungs behind you. This weekend, send the email. Send the text. Make the introduction. Open the door.Because twenty years from now, that person may be standing on a stage like this one, telling the story of their career, and never realizing that today was the day everything changed.
Neal Bhutiani, MD, PhD